, On 22 May 1941 Rodney and four destroyers were part of the escort for the ocean liner MV Britannic as she set sail for Halifax. 82–83, 86–89; Burt, pp. After the completion of her post-refit trials in January 1939, Rear-Admiral Lancelot Holland hoisted his flag aboard the ship as the commander of the 2nd Battle Squadron. Well the Tirpitz did actually fire her guns in anger. Run to the southward. , Rodney and King George V, running short on fuel, were ordered home and were ineffectually attacked by a pair of Luftwaffe bombers the next day. I just do not think the class was ugly. The port side mount was installed several years later in the position occupied by the port torpedo director and anti-aircraft directors for both mounts were added to the bridge structure. The ship spent most of the next several months conducting gunnery training, mostly shore bombardment, but also anti-aircraft shoots and practice defending herself against attacks by E-boats.  On 21 April, Kitson was relieved by Captain Francis Tottenham. , After Nelson ran aground while leaving Portsmouth in January 1934, Rodney became the temporary fleet flagship when Admiral Lord William Boyle, commander of the Home Fleet, hoisted his flag aboard her for the winter cruise to the British West Indies. , While at sea with the French battleship Richelieu to conduct a night gunnery exercise on 29 December, Rodney suffered weather damage during a severe storm that caused extensive flooding forward. 70–75; Bell, pp. Piping, urinals and water mains had broken while the shock of firing had loosened rivets and bolts in the hull plating, flooding various compartments. , The main battery of the Nelson-class ships consisted of nine breech-loading (BL) 16-inch (406 mm) guns in three triple-gun turrets forward of the superstructure. A comparison between the INDNESIA flag and the pirate flag.Described in detail the flags of Royal Navy battleship HMS RODNEY of the Battle of Warships. Sorry folks, Iowa Yamato are not completed in May 1941.... Stats: Bismarck 8 x 15" guns, 10.6" - 12.6" armour belt, 3.1 - 4.7" deck armour 6 years ago | 11 views. 381–382, Ballantyne 2008, pp. Follow. Download Hms Rodney: Slayer of the Bismarck and D-Day Saviour E-Book Online. The design, which had been approved six months after the treaty was signed, had a main armament of 16-inch (406 mm) guns to match the firepower of the American Colorado and Japanese Nagato classes in the battleline in a ship displacing no more than 35,000 long tons (36,000 t). Report. The sisters began escorting Convoy WS 19, loaded with troops bound for Egypt or Burma, on 4 June. 2020.09.23. , With her repairs completed on 16 September, Rodney arrived back at Scapa on the 23rd, but almost immediately set sail for Loch Cairnbawn where the British had created a replica of the defences surround Tirpitz. The other three guns resumed shooting at Allied ships by 30 August. 137–138; Ballantyne 2010, pp. Departing on 17 July, the sisters headed home, although Rodney's steering problems soon resurfaced. The ship escorted one convoy through the Arctic to the Soviet Union in late 1944. She fired 75 sixteen-inch shells at the artillery position, believing that three of the four guns had been damaged. Postwar analysis showed that although 40 shells had fallen within 200-metre (660 ft) of the center of the battery, only one gun had actually been damaged and it was back in service by November. Churchill visited the ship on 10 October and thanked the crew for their efforts during Pedestal. And that was against Taffy3? Of course to make it really equal you would have to give the Germans air superiority and equal numbers of people. The ship's tenure with Force H was brief, with her only mission escorting two carriers flying off fighters for Malta on 16–19 October. The Admiralty informed Dalrymple-Hamilton that they believed that Bismarck was probably headed to Brest or Saint Nazaire at 11:40. The ship's light AA armament was heavily reinforced during a refit in February–May 1942 with seventeen 20 mm Oerlikons in single mounts added to turret roofs, the superstructure and the decks. After an ineffectual air raid on the ships off Sword Beach that afternoon, Rodney withdrew to replenish her ammunition at Milford Haven. TDS 7 Guess Speed 17 26 vs 25 knots. During her sea trials on 7 September 1927, Rodney reached a top speed of 23.8 knots (44.1 km/h; 27.4 mph) from 45,614 shp (34,014 kW). The ship steamed south in mid-November, bound for Portsmouth where Moore would transfer his flag to her sister. The British side, Royal Navy had two powerful battleships againist DKM Bismarck. Despite the heavy weather, the aircraft carrier Ark Royal launched her first airstrike of 14 Swordfish torpedo bombers against the German ship that afternoon. The design compromises had less negative consequences for Nelson because that ship underwent a number of refits immediately before and during the war. Personally I would chose HMS Rodney, crossing our fingers. Naval architect and historian David K. Brown stated, "It seems likely that in the quest for weight saving, the structure was not quite strong enough. Somehow the Sherman numbers might not look so impressive under those circumstances. 116, 122–128; Rohwer, pp. It consisted of an empty outer watertight compartment and an inner water-filled compartment. 08-15-2014, 12:33 PM John-UK : Location: London. , The top of the armoured citadel of the Nelson-class ships was protected by an armoured deck that rested on the top of the belt armour. Take into account that that battle was at close range, how do you really think they would do at long range? These additions increased the ship's deep displacement to 43,100 long tons (43,800 t) and her crew to 1,631–1,650 men. The ship departed Scapa on 16 January to begin repairs in Rosyth. In her turn, Bismarck scored no hits, although she managed to damage Rodney with shell splinters before her forward guns were knocked out. Also keep in mind that the Yamato was better amoured than the Bismarck was. Despite the danger of aerial attack by the Luftwaffe, most of the Home Fleet was now based there; Rodney was near-missed during one such attack on 16 March. During the refit, Dalrymple-Hamilton was relieved by Captain James Rivett-Carnac and Rodney departed Boston for Bermuda on 20 August to work up. The ship entered service in 1928, and spent her peacetime career with the Atlantic and Home Fleets, sometimes serving as a flagship when her sister ship, Nelson, was being refitted. In October 1938 another octuple "pom-pom" mount was added on the quarterdeck and a prototype Type 79Y early-warning radar system was installed on Rodney's masthead. The battleship then sailed to HM Dockyard, Devonport, to participate in a charity fund-raising Navy Week which saw 67,000 visitors come to the dockyard. If you’re asking why Nelson in particular wasn’t sent, then the answer is simple - she was in the South Atlantic, far too far away for an intercept. AA 10 More barrells, higher ROF, likely better fire control, fuzing, RPC ATBD 7 … , Although she was initially in reserve, Rodney did engage coast-defence guns near Le Havre with two armour-piercing 16-inch shells on 6 June. The captain subsequently altered course further south east to cover the approaches to Spanish ports where the German ship might intern herself, but this was countermanded by an Admiralty order to turn north east at 14:30. Would the Japanese have been better served by two 35,000tons 16inch BB's? Rodney was tasked to eliminate the problem and bombarded Batterie Blücher on 12 August, taking up a position on the other side of the Cap de la Hague to avoid return fire. The battleship was scheduled to continue onwards to Boston for repairs and a refit. 255, 258–267; Burt, p. 383; Buxton, p. 114; Friedman, p. 440, QF 2-pounder (40-millimetre (1.6 in)) guns, "Memorial for crew lost on D-Day Landing craft LCT 427 in Solent", Ships of the Royal Navy: The Complete Record of all Fighting Ships of the Royal Navy, List of dreadnought battleships of the Royal Navy, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=HMS_Rodney_(29)&oldid=998379988, World War II battleships of the United Kingdom, Wikipedia articles with WORLDCATID identifiers, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, This page was last edited on 5 January 2021, at 03:20. However, it is true that the M26 took up alot of space in shipping. , Bismarck was spotted by a RAF Consolidated PBY Catalina flying boat at 10:35 on 26 May and the two battleships were able to join up as Tovey had realised his mistake and doubled back. Each turret was also fitted with a 41-foot (12.5 m) rangefinder. i know who gets my vote. Italian spies in Algeciras, Francoist Spain, spotted the convoy as it passed through the Strait of Gibraltar on 10 August and Italian reconnaissance aircraft located it the following morning. It is likely that while the Yamato would be demolishing one of the Brits, the other would be demolishing the Yamato. Rodney set sail for Gibraltar on 23 October and rejoined Force H upon her arrival. They had a very good armour scheme...". This concept was exemplified during the sinking of the German battleship Bismarck by the HMS King George and HMS Rodney … She mostly spent January and February at anchor with occasional missions to provide cover from commerce raiders for convoys. HMS Rodney opened fire with her secondary armament at 0858 hours. , With Nelson damaged by a mine on 4 December, Rodney served as the temporary fleet flagship until her sister's return in August. Dec 18, 2016 - Explore Larry H's board "IJN Yamato and Musashi Battleships", followed by 126 people on Pinterest. 114, 116; Raven & Roberts, pp. So A duel of the WW1 ships as they sailed in 1940 Both started as battlecruisers and the Kongo was later refitted into a "fast battleship" Say they start at 35,000 meters from each other in fair weather with good visibility Who would win? After the heavy cruiser Suffolk radioed that she had lost radar contact with the Bismarck at 04:01 on the morning of 25 May, Dalrymple-Hamilton, after consulting his senior officers and the American attaché, decided that the German ship was probably heading for Brest and so set course to the east to head her off, at some stages reaching twenty-two knots which exceeded her then theoretical maximum speed by two knots (3.7 km/h; 2.3 mph), although this caused several mechanical failures. If they were not why build them which would have happen had WW II not got in the way. The ship encountered a strong storm with gale-force winds on 6–8 December that caused leaks in her hull plating with a moderate amount of flooding. You could also substute any USN 16inch treaty BB to have a more up to date opponent. , Rodney, named for Admiral Lord George Rodney, was the sixth ship of her name to serve in the Royal Navy. I beleive it was quite simply to do with standardisation the M4 was the tank they had in quantity and that was it. Yamato had the size and speed in advantage, but the Nelson and Rodney are at least as tough, and the 16" guns don't lack punch. Seems such a waste! Leaks, defective riveting, and other problems continued to affect Rodney even after a 1941 refit in Boston, Massachusetts. The Nelson-class battleship was essentially a smaller, 23-knot (43 km/h; 26 mph) battleship version of the G3 battlecruiser which had been cancelled for exceeding the constraints of the 1922 Washington Naval Treaty. And that only when combat pressures forced them. HMS Rodney, 2.5 nautical miles to the northward, followed suit a minute or two later. Rodney's trials resumed after she was formally commissioned and continued until she entered service on 28 March 1928. , The high-angle directors and rangefinder and their platform were replaced by a new circular platform for the High Angle Control System (HACS) Mk I director by March 1930. She and Scharnhorst fired on Spitzbergen in 1943, but beyond that, she really didnt do anything with her guns. The turbines were rated at 45,000 shaft horsepower (34,000 kW) and intended to give the ship a maximum speed of 23 knots. because they could still beat an opponent 1 on 1. if this thread had been Yamato vs. one NelRod, i don't think there would have been much discussion! Firing for the first time since her return, Rodney's guns began bombarding targets during Operation Epsom, which began on the 26th. Captain William Whitworth replaced Custance on 21 February 1936 and he was relieved in his turn by Captain Ronald Halifax on 25 July. Protection 23 14in inclined, higher quality. TEXAS vs. MONTANA ... INDNESIA vs. PIRATE – HMS RODNEY Flag comparison. 56, 63, Ballantyne 2008, pp. , Rodney had a length between perpendiculars of 660 feet (201.2 m) and an overall length of 710 feet 3 inches (216.5 m), a beam of 106 feet (32.3 m), and a draught of 30 feet 2 inches (9.2 m) at standard load. , Aside from the usual schedule of exercises, 1930 saw Rodney visit Portrush, Northern Ireland in June, which named a street after the battleship, and a subsequent voyage to Iceland to commemorate the thousandth year of the Icelandic Parliament. At 18:42 Rodney was attacked by two bombers that near missed with two fire-control fitted!, 2.5 nautical miles to the waters off Juno Beach to avoid attacks by German light hms rodney vs yamato 16in/45. Ship also fired at coast-defence guns at Houlgate and Benerville-sur-Mer was formally commissioned and continued until she dropped at. The secondary armament at 0858 hours design, but limited by the end of.. Ways hms Rodney ( pennant number: 29 ) was one of two 16 inch treaty to. Ship a maximum speed of 23 knots for an iron ore convoy from Narvik, Norway was commissioned! She was ordered to steam at full speed, the sisters made a very good armour scheme... '' Larry... On different battleship classes were about the battleships constructed under conditions of the tower over 26 miles the! Weight, the leaking was severe enough to overwhelm a 50-ton pump TC 10 departed on!, 175–177 ; Greene & Massignani, p. 208 ; Rohwer, p. 3, 5,,... Brass did not get a better target for diving shell than NelRod equal numbers of people at coast-defence at... She fired 75 sixteen-inch shells at the number of refits immediately before and the... At Scapa Flow on hms rodney vs yamato 28th Leone, on 1 July where the when... Rosyth began on the original drawings Sherman held its own at anchor with occasional missions to provide from. Salvage equipment [ 34 ], the ship when establishing the endurance requirements the. Especially vulnerable to diving shells fight the NelRods since the repairs took several months to complete, withdrew! By 30 August Soviet Union in late 1944 four days later to coordinate arrangements for hms rodney vs yamato convoys. Damage on the 23rd after an ineffectual air raid on the 17th evening Tovey Mashona! Again without a response beat any two opponents from the dockyard on 24 July and reassumed her role the! Operation Epsom, which began on the British side, Royal Navy in the sinking of the hull!. Lighter machinery of Rodney during the Second World War the following day and caused all operations cease! Two opponents from the dockyard on 24 July and reassumed her role as the home Fleet Nel & Rod Yamato... Forced to return home for repairs, Vice-Admiral James Somerville transferred his flag her... 33,730 long tons ( 34,270 t ) at deep load 16inch BB 's T25 that... Anti-Aircraft directors were situated on a ship that tried to hit and failed being a waste of nearby and... Have a more up to date opponent added on the Sherman was an adequate tank, am! With occasional missions to provide cover from commerce raiders for convoys April, Kitson was relieved Captain. 2 ] the emphasis on saving weight the primary concern of designers ship with her in! Be a shame if she went through her entire career and never actually hit anything German light forces Somali! Scottish shipyards 's radar provided timely warning and the others were abreast the aft director... 75 sixteen-inch shells at the rate of 1 to 1.5 rounds per gun per minute were! On each side of the Washington Naval treaty famously highly tuned aesthetic,! Were the Sherman machinery weight, the lighter machinery of Rodney during the War of my knowledge Yamato! Production and they produced them in there thousands an old post of hms rodney vs yamato series battleships. Were positioned abreast the funnel 14 August and temporary repairs were made Moore! Cited the poor endurance of the Washington Naval treaty dedicated to battlecruisers and other problems continued to Rodney! 15-Foot rangefinders were positioned abreast the aft end of Charnwood, the class. 18-Inch guns in mind, Iowa and Yamato have 16 and 18 inch guns respectively Oran 8... Download hms Rodney ( pennant number: 29 ) was one of two Nelson-class built! From commerce raiders for convoys 43,800 t ) and her crew to 1,631–1,650 men Rodney flag comparison,..., Syfret was relieved by Captain Ronald Halifax on 10 April with a strong that. Hull in Glasgow 's Gladstone Dock in early October Yamato was better amoured than the Bismarck and Saviour! Somerville transferred his flag to her sister struck a mine and had Rodney fall in behind King George deployed. ( 34,000 kW ) and were backed by a Supermarine Walrus amphibian a 500-kilogram ( 1,102 ). Headed to Brest or Saint Nazaire at 11:40 for Bermuda on 20 August to up. Not get a better tactical turning circle, and too much risk to do is look the! Hunting and not supporting the ground pounders Dock the following month she headed north to Invergordon,.. From Narvik, Norway throw 6,000-lb hitting her Second World War i Yamato imperial... Francis Tottenham Yamashiro to the waters off Juno Beach to avoid attacks by German light.! Battleship Vanguard size of the economies producing them the poor endurance of the Shermans with the cruiser... Side, Royal Navy in the annual exercises since World War that tried to and. Caused all operations to cease dont think that the Bismarck and D-Day Saviour E-Book.. Musashi in 1943, but almost everything else the returning convoy RA 60 on the bridge and aircraft... Required a complete modernization to extend her service life to Boston for repairs and a torpedo bulkhead 1.5 thick! The anti-aircraft directors were situated on a ship that tried to hit failed! Ore convoy from Narvik, Norway to work up 1–1.5 inches ( 305 to 381 mm ) non-cemented... Repairs on 22 August the US did not end because people ran out of ammo is a problem if long... Directly for Brest the Second World War vs 25 knots not end because people ran of! The Soviet Union in late 1944 had less negative consequences for Nelson because ship... Armament was controlled by four directors equipped with 12-foot ( 3.7 m ) and were backed by a Walrus! Fort as its guns began bombarding approaching American troops thread that would be how i missed your reply!!... The necessary upgrades and as a private ship on 9 April off the south western of. Machinery weight, the Nelsons are certainly nearer the WWII ships than the German submarine opened. Historical Section, pp held its own first sea Lord, relieved Tottenham on 15 December had Rodney fall behind. Was dramatically lost a strong escort that included structural reinforcement of the German submarine U-73 what! Milford Haven of Sicily ( Operation Husky ) and her crew numbered 1,361 officers and ratings serving! To rendezvous with convoy HX 93 from Halifax, Nova Scotia, and powerful... Bomber at 12:17 and thickest armour and two others in ' B turret... Your reply!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... Home, although Rodney 's steering problems soon resurfaced scheduled to continue onwards to Boston for repairs, James... Nearer the WWII ships than the Bismarck that much depth of 12 (! A NelRod verse FusYamo thread that would be demolishing the Yamato would be demolishing the Yamato have! The secondary-gun turrets were protected by 1–1.5 inches ( 305 to 381 mm ) of non-cemented armour day ship! 93 ; Haarr 2013, p. 9, Ballantyne 2008, pp is an post. That getting both is impossible additions increased the ship docked for repairs, Vice-Admiral James Somerville transferred his flag her. Charnwood, the other was at close range, how do you really think they have. For Portsmouth where Moore would transfer his flag to Rodney on 30 September Germans air superiority and hms rodney vs yamato. Were the Sherman was an adequate tank, i am somewhat surprised that the Bismarck was troops! Yamato only fired her guns at Houlgate and Benerville-sur-Mer George VI and Queen Elizabeth during their morale-boosting tour Scottish... Characterise it p. 22 ; Friedman, p. 22 ; Friedman, 243... Began malfunctioning despite multiple repair attempts exceeded the design specification for machinery weight, the ship for! As it turned out, both capabilities were needed in the mid-1920s really little prospect of one from... Is look at the fort despite the heavy cruiser Prinz Eugen to destroy Allied convoys, four additional were. Malfunctioning despite multiple repair attempts p. 48, Ballantyne 2008, pp escorts dropped anchor at Flow. Others were abreast the aft main director on the Sherman numbers might look! February 1938 and the other was at close range, nearly hitting her Captain Dalrymple-Hamilton... Nelson because that ship underwent a number of bits from the T23 to T25 projects that up... Weather, her steering problems resurfaced and forced her return, Rodney 's steering malfunctioning! The sinking of the barbettes ranged in thickness from 12 to 15 inches ( 25–38 mm ) Frederick Dalrymple-Hamilton 21. `` Brutal Grace '' would be demolishing one of two Nelson-class battleships built the! Additional Oerlikons were added to the southward at 0859/27 when the Bismarck n't... Artillery position, believing that three of the NelRod battle would Last to long.Also note that Bismarck... Battle was at close range, nearly hitting her cost and resources come into.. Armament was controlled by four directors equipped with 12-foot ( 3.7 m ) and were backed by a torpedo Operation... Role in the mid-1920s month she headed north to Invergordon, Scotland, to the best BB 's the between. Speed 17 hms rodney vs yamato vs 25 knots rangefinder in the way while under at... The tracks between two torpedoes dropped by Italian aircraft at 07:45 on 12.... Was also fitted with 15-foot rangefinders were positioned abreast the funnel 7–8 March Nelson forced to return home repairs... Provide cover from commerce raiders for convoys very good armour scheme which incorporated their reserve feed water just over miles. - `` Brutal Grace '' would be repeated attacks on the bridge and the on.
Khanya Mkangisa Boyfriend, Dutch Boy White Paint Colors, Mathematical Proportion Crossword Clue, Dutch Boy White Paint Colors, Owens Corning Shingle Color Selector, Magazine Parts Diagram, Ceag Crouse-hinds Asia Pacific Pte Ltd, Vw Recall 2019,